Film Review: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy


 Immense disappointment was the first thing I felt coming out of this. A film which so much potential, with stars like Firth, Oldman, Cumberbatch and Hardy, the creme de la creme of British acting talent, could contrive to create such a boring, pain-stakingly long piece of work, was beyond me. All the 5 star reviews, et nothing really happened, characters weren’t developed enough to my liking, and only a couple of performances were standout ones for me. It was a real annoyance for something which I’d been waiting to see for so long.

The story revolves around a potential mole planted by the Russians in MI6, the film is spent with Gary Oldman’s character, George Smiley, trying to work out who it is, with himself as one of the suspects. The trouble is, not one of these suspects are given enough of a backstory for the audience to truly care whether they are good or bad. As a result, the eventual reveal isn’t really surprising, but a plot point that lacks real effect, a worrying fact when the whole film is based around it. Perhaps the original TV series, 7 hours long, was the right length for any iteration, as, despite the running time of just over 2 hours, not enough was revealed about these characters.

That being said, the cinematography is excellent. Shots portray the era perfectly, a country on the edge of a potential World War III with the Russians and America lurking around somewhere too. The sense of the suspicion is a running theme throughout and the thoroughness of Smiley is shown as he goes about his daily routine. He is a well-crafted character, credit must be given to Gary Oldman, however, it’s a shame others are not as well developed as him. Some thought is given to the relationship between two supporting characters played by Mark Strong and Firth, resulting in a good climatic scene, but other than that is it is purely Smiley-centric.

The running time of two hours isn’t the longest film you’ll ever see, but it’ll sure feel like it. It starts and ends rather strongly, but for big parts in the middle, I was finding myself dozing off to sleep! At times, scenes of somewhat insignificant things, sugar being poured into tea, a trip to the opticians, are all cut to quickly, which just seemed to be fillers, and became increasingly frustrating as the film progressed. These scenes seemed ridiculous and pointless, time which could’ve been spent giving more of a life to the ‘suspects’.

Tom Hardy and Benedict Cumberbatch provide the best performances of the film, showing that youth does outperform ‘experience’ sometimes. Both are rising stars and it’s clear to see why, with performances that require much emotional depth and a good way of getting themselves across. Hardy is an agent who wants out, and is part of a tragic love-story with the enemy, whilst Cumberbatch is a youthful agent who acts almost as assistant to Smiley, realising how deep he quickly becomes embroiled in everything. Both performances add to what is a rather old, stale affair in terms of acting.

Both opening and end scenes end with a ‘bang’ so to speak and, ironically, are probably the best parts of the film! The backing track of ‘La Mer’, in the end scene, worked well as any emotion was drawn out by the events which were happening on-screen. Strangely enough the music made me happy, a stark contrast to the on-screen events, maybe it was the music, or maybe, just maybe it was because this rather long, boring film had finally ended.


10 thoughts on “Film Review: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy

  1. Nice review. I agree with much of what you say, the film should come with a disclaimer: “This film will hurt your head and make you confused”.

    I was on the fence for a while as I was either going to give a really high, or low score. In the end, I decided that I was glued to the screen and I had a great time trying to guess the ending.

    It certainly isn’t easy watching.

    Oh yeah, I am following you now!

  2. Love how we both mentioned the song at the end!

    Thank you for checking out my review. I know I send it up a lot, but I still understand every point you are making.

    And you are oh so spot on when it comes to Hardy and Cumberbatch!

  3. I came here from Iamnotwayneeagle’s review and although I am still excited about watching this film maybe I wont walk in to the cinema with too many expectations after all of the hype. Maybe this will avoid any possible disappointments should there be any.

    Thanks for the flipside review.


    1. Thanks a lot! Speaking to others, many have felt the same as me, others like your friend’s review, so it looks like it’s just a Marmite film to be honest, enjoy though!

  4. At the end of the day, you’ve got to go in trying to expect nothing. But that’s impossible….! I was disappointed with X-Men: First Class due to the reviews and was really surprised by The Hangover Part II. Let’s hope we don’t have anything to worry about when The Dark Knight Rises comes along….. In Nolan We Trust!!

  5. Oh my goodness I cannot agree more about that comment at the end. I was so relieved once it was over. It dragged on the plot was dull and it was over stylised. I do not get why everyone has been raving about it. Love your blog and have subscribed. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s